Uli's Web Site
[ Zathras.de - Uli's Web Site ]
Other Sites: Stories
Abi 2000
Stargate: Resurgence
Lost? Site Map!
     home | blog | moose | programming | articles >> blog

 Blog Topics

15 Most Recent [RSS]

 Less work through Xcode and shell scripts
2011-12-16 @600
 iTunesCantComplain released
2011-10-28 @954
 Dennis Ritchie deceased
2011-10-13 @359
 Thank you, Steve.
2011-10-06 @374
 Cocoa Text System everywhere...
2011-03-27 @788
 Blog migration
2011-01-29 @520
 All you need to know about the Mac keyboard
2010-08-09 @488
 Review: Sherlock
2010-07-31 @978
 Playing with Objective C on Debian
2010-05-08 @456
 Fruit vs. Obst
2010-05-08 @439
 Mixed-language ambiguity
2010-04-15 @994
 Uli's 12:07 AM Law
2010-04-12 @881
 Uli's 1:24 AM Law
2010-04-12 @874
 Uli's 6:28 AM Law
2010-04-12 @869
 Uli's 3:57 PM Law
2010-04-12 @867


Why from-scratch rewrites are bad

I just found a very good article on why from-scratch rewrites of source code aren't always a good idea:

Things you should never do - Part I

There's also an another article on this topic at HelpfulTiger. It covers one point that this one doesn't say much about: Code Ownership. While Joel is right that many rewrites are done for the wrong reasons and in situations where refactoring the code would have sufficed, rewriting code can help your developers take ownership of the software, and will make them more effective because they know the code very intimately.

However, such rewrites require that the developer(s) who do the rewrite will stay with your company for a while. If someone comes in to rewrite your source code and then disappear, none of the developers that will later be updating the application have gained much from this rewrite. They'll simply have exchanged the set of old bugs with a set of new ones.

Heed Joel's advice; don't rewrite just because code is ugly. Refactor the existing code instead. But if you really feel compelled to rewrite, make sure the person doing the rewrite will stay in the company.

Update: Andrew pointed out that I was talking about his article. So I added the link.

Created: 2005-02-20 @658 Last change: 2005-02-20 @827 | Home | Admin | Edit
© Copyright 2003-2023 by M. Uli Kusterer, all rights reserved.